Subject

Roberto Esposito: Chaos and Catastrophe

Andrea Cavalletti

This interview by writer and researcher Andrea Cavalletti with Roberto Esposito, a leading Italian philosopher whose work is internationally recognised and widely translated, takes as its point of departure a book co-authored by Esposito and Massimo Cacciari, precisely entitled Kaos – the chaos that determines contemporary politics and into which ‘the very form of the world’ has been transformed.

George Bellows Both Members of This Club [Ambos membros deste clube], 1909 Óleo sobre tela 115 × 160,5 cm © Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio

George Bellows, Both Members of This Club [Ambos membros deste clube], 1909 © Cleveland Museum of Art, Ohio

‘Chaos means the undifferentiated Void in itself, the Open as a gaping mouth before any sound has been uttered. Relations and harmonies, as well as contradictions and confusions, are born from Chaos […] And they can return to its immense Void […] Chaos […] will necessarily generate new “Orders”, which may resemble Mondrian’s clear geometry or, on the contrary – we can never know – an apocalypse by Anselm Kiefer.’ So reads the introduction to Kaos (2026), a book published by two of Italy’s most prominent philosophers, Massimo Cacciari and Roberto Esposito.

Roberto Esposito himself graciously agreed to answer our questions. A leading representative and theorist of Italian Theory, Esposito is the author of more than 30 books, which have been translated into several languages. These include Categories of the Impolitical, 2015 (1988), Communitas: The Origin and Destiny of Community, 2009 (1998), Immunitas: The Protection and Negation of Life, 2011 (2002), Bios: Biopolitics and Philosophy, 2008 (2004), Third Person: Politics of Life and Philosophy of the Impersonal, 2012 (2007), Two: The Machine of Political Theology and the Place of Thought, 2015 (2013), Instituting Thought: Three Paradigms of Political Ontology, 2021 (2020), and his most recent book, Il fascismo e noi. Un’interpretazione filosofica [Fascism and Us: A Philosophical Interpretation] (2025). In these works, he has rethought a series of fundamental philosophical and political paradigms and, in creative dialogue with Foucauldian theory, developed an entirely original conception of biopolitics that has had a wide impact on international debate. Renewing a longstanding philosophical friendship and their shared experience of significant intellectual exchanges, he has co-authored his latest book with Massimo Cacciari. Also known in Italy for his strong political engagement – among other things, Cacciari was a member of parliament for the Italian Communist Party (PCI) from 1976 to 1983 and served three terms as mayor of Venice – Cacciari is also the author of an extensive body of work, including Krisis (1976), Posthumous People: Vienna at the Turning Point, 1996 (1980), Icone della legge [Icons of the Law] (1985), The Necessary Angel, 1994 (1986), Dell’inizio [On the Beginning] (1990), Della cosa ultima [On the Last Thing] (2004), and Metafisica concreta [Concrete Metaphysics] (2023), which together constitute a genuine philosophical system.

Kaos consists of two texts that are as independent as they are closely interconnected. The result of a dialogue the two authors have sustained for many years, the book also emerges from a shared view of the present, from the urgency of a joint recognition: today, a planetary struggle is taking place between the homogenising and pervasive rationality of technology and the resistance of the great political spaces. And ‘in this confrontation, in which all empires, including the American one, seem to be losing control of their own destiny, Kaos becomes the very form of the world.’

ANDREA CAVALLETTI  The book Kaos, which you wrote with Massimo Cacciari, revolves around a central thesis: chaos is not only the most evident feature of the politics of this century but, more fundamentally, determines it. Are we therefore dealing with something that goes far beyond disorder?

ROBERTO ESPOSITO  Before political philosophy even begins to answer this question, it is mythology that does so, as Cacciari reminds us in his essay, drawing on Hesiod. Chaos is not disorder – or mere confusion – not least because the very concept of ‘disorder’ necessarily presupposes that of ‘order’, of which it is the dialectical negative. Our approach consists in thinking chaos without passing through order, without presupposing order. From this point of view, chaos is the bottomless pit from which all possible orders and disorders emerge. If we approach it from a theological perspective, chaos is Nothingness, the Void, from which God creates everything. From a psychoanalytic perspective, it is the Unconscious from which all conscious contents arise before sinking back into it. In philosophical terms, chaos is the latency, or potentiality, from which every actualisation emerges. As the originary Void, it is neither negative nor, still less, positive. It precedes, and in a certain sense deconstructs, the opposition between positive and negative. More than a ‘position’, it is a ‘pre-supposition’, something ‘presupposed’, which precedes every position. But chaos – in the deepest sense of the term – cannot even be compared with a mere crisis, although we continue to resort to this inadequate expression in order to define it. A crisis is a process in which the preceding order is reorganised by different means. A crisis is a bottleneck which, once overcome, makes the previous order stronger. In a crisis, unlike in chaos, we know what we should be striving for: the reconstitution of order. Consider what capitalist crises have been: forms of restructuring capital. The same applies to the government crises of Christian Democratic Italy, whose purpose was to alter the balance of forces without changing the system. These are always reconstructive movements, the reconstitution of the preceding order on new foundations; crises of growth, intended to neutralise the most intense conflicts through a readjustment of the old system. The radical chaos we now face is very different, and is more akin to the concept of catastrophe, understood in its etymological sense as a change of state. A genuine change of state is one that radically and unpredictably alters the preceding situation.

"Chaos – in the deepest sense of the term – cannot even be compared with a mere crisis, although we continue to resort to this inadequate expression in order to define it […]. In a crisis, unlike in chaos, we know what we should be striving for: the reconstitution of order."

AC  The century opened with September 11th, and this event marks a point of chaotic irruption. Should we think in terms of a long latency, of a series of warning signs? As though chaos could penetrate and act within apparent order in such a way as to produce a rupture?

RE  Yes, September 11th was only the final explosion of an order that had long been displaying profound signs of fracture, all of which eventually converged in the collapse of the Twin Towers. In the previous decade, beginning with the fall of the Berlin Wall and, consequently, of the entire Soviet bloc, the West lived under the illusion that a new unipolar order – centred on the United States of America – could replace, without new global conflicts, the bipolar order that had governed the world since the end of the Second World War. It was the entirely illusory moment in which people could speak of the triumph of liberal democracy and even of the end of history. In reality, as later became clear, things were very different. Not only were new empires emerging – beginning with China and then, gradually, Russia itself, not to mention middle powers such as India, Turkey, and Brazil – but the Western democracies themselves, beginning with that of the United States, were undergoing a radical political crisis that was undermining the entire neoliberal order. Although this latter constituted the dominant form in the West, it had from the outset been undermined by a series of contradictions that are now plain for all to see. Globalisation itself, which had seemed both inevitable and essentially beneficial, proved to be anything but a peaceful process, one destined to unify the world in the form of division – between the privileged few and the disadvantaged many. The 2001 attack, in short, did no more than give striking expression to the advancing chaos, which has now reached its maximum point of explosion in a convergence of events that are all potentially catastrophic: the economic crisis of 2007, the pandemic, environmental collapse, and the war currently being fought both within Europe and along its borders.

"The 2001 attack did no more than give striking expression to the advancing chaos, which has now reached its maximum point of explosion in a convergence of events that are all potentially catastrophic."

AC  In this respect, your definition of chaotic ambivalence is decisive and genuinely illuminating. On the one hand, chaos would be able to annihilate any order, swallowing it up like a black hole; on the other, however, ‘the further chaos spreads, the more it demands the possibility of a new order’. Is there a new idea, or a new political philosophy, at stake here capable of meeting this demand? That is, to use a term from the last century, the possibility of a ‘non-catastrophic’ politics?

RE  In terms of political philosophy, something that can be likened to chaos, at least in certain respects, is what Thomas Hobbes calls the ‘state of nature’, or rather a widespread conflict that threatens the very existence of human beings. This comes to an end with the construction of the Leviathan State, born from the social pact. But the mythological figure, used by Hobbes himself, that most closely resembles contemporary chaos is another biblical monster, Behemoth: a many-headed monster whose heads devour one another. Behemoth, according to Hobbes, is civil war, a radical disorder corresponding to the ‘fragmented civil war’ that characterises our present condition. The problem we face is that no Leviathan can be set against such a conflict, since Behemoth – that is, chaos – has penetrated the state itself and, above all, relations between states. Today, no state is capable of resisting either the dissolutive forces that threaten it from within or those that assail it from outside.

[...]